Trade & logistics news

Claro Customs — licensed U.S. and Canada customs brokerage with AI-assisted processing.

Get a Demo

Supreme Court sends Casarez shipper liability case back

FreightWaves reporter John Kingston wrote on November 17, 2026 that the U.S. Supreme Court acted the day before, Monday, November 16, in Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms et al. (https://www.freightwaves.com/news/scotus-action-revives-shipper-receiver-liability-post-montgomery). The Court issued a Grant, Vacate, Remand (GVR) order, which sends the case back to a California appellate court without ruling on the merits. This is a legal development to watch, not a new rule, and it does not decide whether shippers or receivers are liable.

According to FreightWaves, Fresno County Superior Court granted summary judgment to Irigoyen Farms and Walmart in September 2023 on the basis of federal preemption under the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (FAAAA). The Fifth Appellate District affirmed in September 2025, and the California Supreme Court denied review in January 2026. The case arises from a September 2019 crash near Fresno involving a truck driver hauling produce from Irigoyen in Selma, California, to a Walmart distribution center in Nevada, on a load arranged through a chain of logistics companies.

The picture changed in May 2026, with the decision in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II. That decision held that the FAAAA safety exception, which includes the phrase "with respect to motor vehicles," can apply to brokers. FreightWaves reports that this undercut the reasoning of the lower courts in Casarez.

The open industry question is whether shippers or freight recipients can face liability in a similar way. FreightWaves cites attorney Gregory Reed of Hanson Bridgett calling it the most important shipper-receiver liability case to watch, while saying it is unclear that a monumental ruling will follow. Reed noted that the Court passed on whether shippers and receivers can invoke FAAAA preemption and that there is no circuit split yet. Walmart said it will continue to defend itself in the California Court of Appeal.

What this means for importers: companies that ship or receive freight across the U.S.-Canada border should treat this as background, not a change in the rules. Outcomes in cases like this may depend on the facts, the court and the legal theory involved, and the case now returns to a lower court. This is general information, not legal advice, so questions about contracts or liability are best raised with your own counsel.

Moving freight across the U.S.-Canada border? We can help file the entry. Claro handles U.S. and Canada customs entries 24/7. Standard document processing takes 15 minutes, and if your entry isn't done within 30 minutes of complete documents reaching our email, Claro's brokerage fee for that entry is free.*

*Duties, taxes and government fees still apply. This covers document processing only; release or holds by Customs and other government agencies are outside our control.

Summarized by Claro from the original source. For official details, see the source link.

How Claro can help

Claro provides customs clearance and compliance support for imports into the U.S. and Canada. Our licensed brokers and AI-assisted systems help ensure your shipments clear quickly.

Related Services

NEED HELP WITH YOUR IMPORTS?

Get expert customs support

Our team of licensed brokers and trade specialists can help you navigate customs requirements and stay compliant.